New guidance is asking “civil servants to break the law”, says FDA

FDA General Secretary Dave Penman has strongly criticised new guidance issued to civil servants, as it puts them in an “invidious position” and calls into question the integrity of the civil service, which has an obligation to uphold the rule of law, whether that is domestic or international law.
The guidance states that decisions whether to comply with a Rule 39 injunction from the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) and the “implications of such a decision in respect of the UK’s international obligations are a matter for ministers”, not civil servants.
Penman argued there is a clear difference between not asking civil servants to breach international law, and telling them not to worry about breaching international law. He told the Guardian that “changing guidance… does not change the facts… If the ECHR rules a deportation unlawful, those are the facts of the case”.
“Ministers are trying to put civil servants in an invidious position by placing them between serving ministers and their professional obligations, he added. “It looks as if ministers are trying to avoid leaving the ECHR and are asking civil servants to break the law instead.”
Speaking to John Pienaar on Times Radio, the General Secretary said that he interprets the new guidance as ministers putting civil servants in the middle of “an internal dispute within the Conservative Party”.
Related News
-
FDA reps in Dstl awarded the Group Impact Award 2025
Katherine Hutchinson speaks to the winners of the Group Impact Award 2025: FDA reps Gareth Conway, Karen Craddock, Matt Gibb and Simon Botting at the Defence Science and Technology Laboratory (Dstl).
-
Structure over speed: Dame Wendy Hall on artificial intelligence in the civil service
Professor Dame Wendy Hall shares how artificial intelligence can assist the civil service, but shouldn’t be treated as a quick fix.
-
Inside UK PLC: Penman discusses recent trip to Warsaw with FCDO
In May, FDA General Secretary Dave Penman visited Warsaw and its embassy to help highlight the significant work of our Foreign, Commonwealth and Development staff, based in countries across the globe.