Penman in CSW: Civil service chiefs’ morning of herding the Alpacas

In his latest column for Civil Service World, FDA General Secretary Dave Penman reviews Cabinet Secretary Sir Mark Sedwill and Civil Service Chief Executive John Manzoni’s latest appearance in front of the Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Select Committee – or “Alpacas” for short.
After opening exchanges relating to the “classic Alpaca territory” of leadership academies, immersive case studies and the loss of the National School of Government, discussions moved on to “the issue that really gets their collective juices flowing” – Brexit.
While “head Alpaca Brexit Bernie” was concerned that people should be talking more positively about Brexit, concerns were also raised over the use of the term “disorderly Brexit”.
As Sedwill and Manzoni did their best to explain that contingency planning meant anticipating the worst-case scenario as well, Penman observed that they were “a bit damned if they do, damned if they don’t”.
“The government has been criticised for not planning for no deal,” he writes. “But when it does and includes the worst-case scenarios it’s all ‘project fear’ analogies.”
Read the full column here.
Related News
-
Structure over speed: Dame Wendy Hall on artificial intelligence in the civil service
Professor Dame Wendy Hall shares how artificial intelligence can assist the civil service, but shouldn’t be treated as a quick fix.
-
The engine room of reform: speeches from ADC 2025
As well as lively debates on motions, the 2025 Annual Delegate Conference also heard from three main speakers: Parliamentary Secretary at the Cabinet Office Georgia Gould, FDA General Secretary Dave Penman, and journalist and broadcaster Lewis Goodall.
-
“An opportunity missed”
Dave Penman has labelled new Commission “an opportunity missed” and called on the government to go further and look at parliament for a more independent system.